Meet Our Staff

Rev. John Inserra

senior pastor

Rev. John Inserra came to Sheridan, Wyoming after serving an Episcopal Church and School in New Orleans, Louisiana. A cradle Episcopalian and a native of Buffalo, New York, Fr. John attended seminary in Nashotah, Wisconsin at Nashotah House Theological Seminary. Fr. John has been married to his wife, Sarah, since 2006. They have one daughter together named Rosina.

Dr. John Milliken

Assistant for Discipleship

John came to St. Peter’s in August, 2013. A native of the Midwest, he spent two years teaching philosophy in Lithuania before coming to Sheridan. He and his wife, Rachel, have been married thirteen years and have two children: Chayah (9), and Noah (7).

Karon Keahy

Parish Secretary

Karon has been with St. Peter’s since 2013 and is a long-time resident of Sheridan. She has been married to her husband Bruce for 40 years and has two grown children. Her commitment to Christ fuels her service.

Gail Boyer

Parish Administrator


Suzie Schatz-Benson

Choir Director

Jeannene McKnight


Shawn Guilliams


Patrick Henderson

Sr. Warden

Robert Prusak

Jr. Warden

Juanita Smith